FSB: Post-Brexit immigration system must address Scotland’s needs

Press Releases 27 Jan 2020

FSB comment on the publication of the Scottish Government's 'Migration: Helping Scotland prosper' report

The Federation of Small Businesses (FSB) in Scotland has broadly welcomed the publication today (27 January) of the Scottish Government’s report, “Migration: Helping Scotland Prosper”.

The report follows a series of recent announcements from the UK Government about the immigration system – notably that businesses will have less than a year to prepare for a new points-based system.

FSB Scotland has previously highlighted the importance of workers from the EU to the success of small businesses, with one in four employers relying on staff from the EU.

Andrew McRae, FSB’s Scotland policy chair, said:

“The immigration system is about to undergo its most dramatic transformation in decades at breakneck speed – with the new system due to be up and running in a little over eleven months’ time. This self-imposed timescale should not preclude the possibility of a UK system working for the needs of Scotland’s small business community.

“The new paper from the Scottish Government is a timely and evidence-based intervention. It sets out a pathway towards a UK system that can flex for Scotland’s distinct demographic and economic needs, without creating additional burdens for smaller businesses.

“The UK Government should acknowledge that it is possible and desirable to enable its immigration system to respond to different regions and nations, as well as maintain strict border controls and a user-friendly system.”

The Migration Advisory Committee (MAC) is likely to publish its report later this week on salary thresholds, including the proposed £30,000, and how an “Australian-style points-based system” could work in the UK.

New FSB research is arguing for a £20,100 salary threshold because:

  • No small employers in Scotland pay their “lower-skilled” staff £30,000 or more – e.g. care workers and childcare workers
  • Around one in five small employers (16%) pay salaries of £30,000 or more in mid-skilled jobs – e.g. hotel managers and plumbers

Andrew McRae added: “Given pay levels in Scotland are lower than London and the South East, setting a salary threshold at £30,000 is completely unworkable for the small business community.

“At a time when many employers are planning for an uncertain post-Brexit future, it would exclude the vast majority of employers that currently rely on EU workers and cause serious disruption to the economy. If a threshold has to be set, it should be at more sensible level of £20,100 for overseas workers.”


  • The Scottish Government’s paper on migration can be found here.
  • The MAC’s consultation can be found here.

About FSB

As experts in business, FSB offers members a wide range of vital business services, including advice, financial expertise, support and a powerful voice in Government. Its aim is to help smaller businesses achieve their ambitions. 

Media contacts

Colin Borland
Director of Devolved Nations
Email: [email protected]
Telephone: 07917 628939